| July 2023 Supplemental Draft | |||||||||||||
| TEAM | add R1 | add R2 | add R3 | add R4 | add R5 | add R6 | drop R1 | drop R2 | drop R3 | drop R4 | drop R5 | drop R6 | |
| Derek VanRiper/Ryan Bloomfield | Emmet Sheehan | Joey Votto | Jonny DeLuca | Robert Suarez | PASS | PASS | Luis Urias | Tylor Megill | Tucupita Marcano | Roansy Contreras | PASS | PASS | |
| Brian Feldman | Andrew Abbott | Dairon Blanco | Keaton Winn | PASS | PASS | PASS | Matthew Liberatore | Corey Dickerson | DL Hall | PASS | PASS | PASS | |
| Greg Ambrosius/Dean Peterson | Luis Matos | Cody Bradford | Jordan Diaz | Carson Kelly | Victor Mederos | Adrian Houser | Gabriel Arias | Pavin Smith | Noah Syndergaard | Christian Vazquez | Lance McCullers Jr. | Adam Frazier | |
| Perry Van Hook | Kolby Allard | Jose Soriano | Bryce Johnson | PASS | PASS | PASS | Jacob DeGrom | Trayce Thompson | Romy Gonzalez | PASS | PASS | PASS | |
| Ron Shandler | David Peterson | Samad Taylor | Jose A. Ferrer | Matt Strahm | pass | PASS | Brandon Crawford | Bubba Thompson | Kyle Gibson | Benny Montgomery | PASS | PASS | |
| Tim McLeod/Josh Paley | Will Benson | Jason Foley | Griffin Jax | Blake Perkins | pass | PASS | Adalberto Mondesi | Jose Trevino | Grant Anderson | Mark Vientos | PASS | PASS | |
| Todd Zola | Kutter Crawford | Jose Quintana | RIch Hill | pass | PASS | PASS | Akil Baddoo | Chris Taylor | Nick Senzel | PASS | PASS | PASS | |
| Jeff Winick | Taijuan Walker | J.P. Crawford | Edward Olivares | PASS | PASS | PASS | Mike Zunino | Charlie Blackmon | Jose Urquidy | PASS | PASS | PASS | |
| Doug Dennis | Eddie Rosario | Kyle Hendricks | pass | pass | PASS | PASS | Oswaldo Cabrera | Wil Myers | PASS | PASS | PASS | PASS | |
| Jeff Erickson | Mickey Moniak | Cristopher Sanchez | Eduardo Escobar | Andrew Nardi | PASS | PASS | Josh Fleming | Robbie Grossman | Rodolfo Castro | Giovanny Gallegos | PASS | PASS | |
| Peter Kreutzer/Alex Patton | Jordan Hicks | Jared Young | Kirby Yates | Donovan Solano | PASS | PASS | Gio Urshela | Chase Anderson | Ben Lively | Luis Patino | PASS | PASS | |
| Eric Karabell/Tristan Cockcroft | Graham Ashcraft | Drey Jameson | A.J. Minter | pass | PASS | PASS | Matthew Boyd | Nate Pearson | Seranthony Dominguez | PASS | PASS | PASS | |
| Brian Walton | Scott McGough | Corey Julks | Nick Madrigal | Tony Kemp | PASS | PASS | Brandon Williamson | Mitch Haniger | Jurickson Profar | Brandon Crawford | Nick Senzel | Dylan Floro | |
| Jason Collette | Andy Ibanez | Dane Dunning | David Hamilton | Stone Garrett | PASS | PASS | Bobby Dalbec | Nick Pivetta | Yoan Moncada | Ji-Hwan Bae | PASS | PASS | |
| Steve Gardner/Ian Kahn | Nick Gonzales | Kerry Carpenter | Trevor May | Mike Moustakas | pass | PASS | Mark Leiter Jr. | Yennier Cano | Jameson Taillon | Josh Rojas | PASS | PASS | |